What is the difference between cubic zirconia and diamond?

Wat is het verschil tussen zirkonia en diamant?
Geschreven door: Sharon van het Hof

Cubic zirconia sparkles like a diamond and costs a fraction of the price. That immediately raises the question of what exactly differs.

The answer is: almost everything, except their appearance from a distance. Below, we compare the facts side by side.

Uneven Pendant Zirconia

Uneven Pendant Zirconia

They are two completely different materials

Diamond consists of pure carbon, whose atoms are arranged in an extremely tight lattice. That lattice formed deep in the Earth’s mantle under enormous pressure.

Cubic zirconia is zirconium dioxide stabilized with yttrium or calcium. It grows in a furnace at roughly 2,700 degrees and is virtually never found in this form in nature.

Its full name is cubic zirconia, often abbreviated to CZ. Do not confuse it with zircon, which is a completely different natural mineral.

Hardness: the biggest difference

Diamond ranks at the top of the Mohs scale with a 10. Cubic zirconia scores around 8 to 8.5.

That may seem close, but the Mohs scale is not linear. In absolute terms, diamond is many times more scratch-resistant than cubic zirconia.

In practice, this means that after years of wear, cubic zirconia develops fine scratches along its facet edges. As a result, the stone gradually looks duller, while diamond retains its brilliance.

Why does cubic zirconia sparkle differently?

Diamond has a refractive index of approximately 2.42, while cubic zirconia has one of 2.15. Diamond therefore bends light more strongly and reflects more bright, white flashes.

Cubic zirconia, on the other hand, has higher dispersion, the property that splits white light into colours. Its rainbow flashes are stronger than those of diamond.

With some practice, you can recognize the difference. Cubic zirconia looks more colourful and almost too sparkly, while diamond produces a crisper, white brilliance.

Pendant Clip Leaf Zirconia

Pendant Clip Leaf Zirconia

Weight gives it away immediately

Cubic zirconia is considerably heavier. Its specific gravity is around 5.7, compared with approximately 3.5 for diamond.

Two stones of the same size therefore differ significantly in weight. With a loose stone, you can feel the difference immediately in your hand.

In a piece of jewellery, you notice it in the pendant. A large cubic zirconia weighs more than you might expect, which is relevant to the strain on your chain.

Other practical differences

Inclusions

Diamond grows naturally and almost always contains small inclusions. Cubic zirconia is made in a furnace and is generally perfectly clean.

A stone that looks absolutely flawless at a low price is therefore more likely to be cubic zirconia than an exceptional diamond.

Thermal conductivity

Diamond conducts heat exceptionally well and therefore feels cold to the touch. Cubic zirconia is a poor conductor. Jewellers use this difference in testing equipment.

Price

This is where the most familiar gap lies. Cubic zirconia is affordable because it grows in a matter of weeks and is produced in large quantities.

So is cubic zirconia an inferior choice?

Not necessarily, as long as you know what you are buying. Cubic zirconia offers plenty of sparkle at a low price, making bold designs more affordable.

It only becomes problematic when it is sold as diamond. On the Sparkling Jewels pendants, cubic zirconia is clearly stated in the product name, and the base is 925 sterling silver.

Browse the pendant collection to see which designs use cubic zirconia.

Twist Pendant Pink Opalite

Twist Pendant Pink Opalite

How do you keep cubic zirconia looking beautiful?

Store the pendant separately, because with a rating of 8 on the Mohs scale, cubic zirconia can scratch almost any natural stone and is itself only scratched by diamond.

Clean it with lukewarm water, a drop of mild soap and a soft brush along the facet edges. This is where dirt accumulates, and it is exactly what takes away the sparkle.

If you wear several pendants together, do not place cubic zirconia directly against a softer stone. Read more about this in wearing multiple pendants on one chain.

Frequently asked questions

Here are answers to some frequently asked questions:

Does cubic zirconia become dull over time?

The stone itself does not change, but fine scratches on the facet edges reduce its brilliance. A jeweller can polish this if desired.

Is cubic zirconia the same as moissanite?

No. Moissanite is silicon carbide, harder with a rating of 9.25, and produces even stronger rainbow brilliance.

What is the difference between cubic zirconia and zircon?

Zircon is a natural mineral found in the Earth’s crust. Cubic zirconia is man-made. The names are similar, but the materials are not.

Can I identify cubic zirconia at home?

Weight is the most helpful clue, because cubic zirconia is noticeably heavier at the same size. Only a test by a jeweller can provide certainty.

Does cubic zirconia change colour?

The material itself does not. However, the finish on the setting may discolour, making the stone look less bright.

Would you like to know more, or do you have any questions? The experts at Sparkling Jewels will be happy to help.